• Home
  • About Us
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
  • Login

Join In!

  • facebook
  • pinterest
  • twitter

Progressive Women's Leadership

Empowering. Supportive. Bold

EMPOWERING. SUPPORTIVE. BOLD.
  • Training
    • Career Development
    • Communication
    • Leadership
  • All-Access
  • Custom
  • eGuides
  • Blog
    • Leadership
    • Communication
    • Community
    • Life Balance
    • Gender Partnerships
    • Women in the World
  • Resources
    • Free Leadership E-Guides
    • Podcasts
You are here: Home / Featured Home / New court ruling on equal pay a victory for women everywhere

New court ruling on equal pay a victory for women everywhere

April 16, 2018 By Jennifer Azara

Here’s news every woman in the workforce needs to know: Your salary history can’t be used a justification for paying you less than your male colleagues.

That’s the upshot of a new U.S. federal appeals court ruling.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that “prior salary alone or in combination with other factors cannot justify a wage differential.” That’s an about-face on a previous ruling in this same case.

The reasoning? That paying a woman less for the same work because she’s made less in the past will perpetuate the wage gap forever.

Check out the specific of the case and how you can use it to your own advantage.

The specifics

The woman in this case sued her employer, claiming it violated the Equal Pay Act by paying her less than her male colleagues for the same work.

And the company didn’t deny that. But it asserted it had a factor “other than sex” to justify it, which is allowed by law. Specifically, it said the decision was based on the female employee’s past pay.

But the 3-person judicial panel wasn’t having it.

Yes, it acknowledged that federal law allows for discrepancies between what men and women make based on legitimate business reasons. But salary history can’t be a reason for it. That’s because, according to the court: Prior salary is not “a legitimate measure of work experience, ability, performance, or any other job-related quality.”

May be applied to other circumstances

Clearly this is important insight for all of you who are looking for a job. What you made at a previous job can’t be used as a reason to justify paying you less than what the men make in that position.

But there are even broader implications for women everywhere in this case.

While this specific ruling applied to an initial salary set with an employer, the language in the ruling is such that experts believe the same logic can also apply to promotions and job transfers.

 Cite: Rizo v. Yovino.

Recommended For You

  • Another court victory for women on equal pay claimsAnother court victory for women on equal pay claims
  • Decision fatigue: Do you have it? Does your team?Decision fatigue: Do you have it? Does your team?
  • New proof: ‘Nice’ girls finish last … in the hunt for a new jobNew proof: ‘Nice’ girls finish last … in the hunt for a new job
  • Giving Praise That Sticks: Going Above and Beyond ‘Good Job!’Giving Praise That Sticks: Going Above and Beyond ‘Good Job!’
  • To Fight Unconscious Bias, We’ve Got To Recognize ItTo Fight Unconscious Bias, We’ve Got To Recognize It
  • What’s the game plan to fix the gender pay gap?What’s the game plan to fix the gender pay gap?
  • Managing Millennials: Winning Over the Next Generation of LeadersManaging Millennials: Winning Over the Next Generation of Leaders
  • Finding the Right Level of Empathy: Do You Have Too Little (or Too Much)?Finding the Right Level of Empathy: Do You Have Too Little (or Too Much)?

Filed Under: Featured Home, Leadership Tagged With: appeals court, court, Equal Pay Act, past pay, pay, ruling, salary history

About Jennifer Azara

“I just love bossy women. I could be around them all day. To me, bossy is not a pejorative term at all. It means somebody’s passionate and engaged and ambitious and doesn’t mind leading.” -- Amy Poehler, Actress
 
I’m thrilled to have recently joined Progressive Women’s Leadership in the role of Managing Editor. I’ve worked as a writer and editor for more than 18 years, covering a variety of “beats” from CFOs to warehouse workers. But this is the one I’m most excited about. The key to editorial success is to be in constant contact with your audience – find out what info they need, what keeps them up at night. Then work tirelessly to give them that with every story. I want our site to be the first resource you go to when you have a challenge at work. This bossy woman is ready to get down to business!

Looking to Make a Difference?

Join thousands of other leading women who have made the commitment to change.

GET MORE INFORMATION

KEEP UP WITH THE LATEST

Updates, discounts and content from Progressive Women’s Leadership straight to your inbox. Your information will never be sold or distributed.

Negotiating Skills: How to Ask for – and Get – What You Want | Course | Starts November 2nd

Popular Posts

  • Why It Pays to Praise: 40 Ways to Say ‘Good Job’
  • Employees complaining about pay? How to respond – and keep morale high
  • Efficient Communication: How to Say More with Less
  • 6 Tools for Handling Difficult Conversations
  • 3 Steps to Take Next Time You’re Blindsided at Work
Progressive Women's Leadership

Training

  • Live Training
  • On-Demand Webinars
  • Custom Training

Blog Topics

  • Leadership
  • Communication
  • Community
  • Life Balance
  • Gender Partnerships
  • Women in the World

Leadership E-Guides

 

Free Resources

  • Free Leadership E-Guides
  • Podcasts

Copyright © 2022 · Progressive Women's Leadership · Privacy Policy

WELCOME BACK!

Enter your username and password below to log in

Forget Your Username or Password?

Reset Password

Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.

Log In